SEO Indexing Issue

From an SEO perspective our site specifically has over a decade and a half's worth of domain authority, and our site has dense content. Not being attached to TMI at this age of our club should have an immaterial impact, in my opinion.

It looks like we have bingbot disabled, and Yahoo! is using bingbot for Yahoo! search, not Slurp anymore:
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yahoo!_Slurp

That is probably why bing webmaster tools are giving me an "unspecified error" when I do a fetch as bingbot.

If no bing search results, then no yahoo search results, either.