tpetchy, aside from your problem with the checkbox setting not saving, I think you are misinterpreting the agenda views. The view you are looking at is only available to the site admin, and VPE. All roles have to be assigned and this is where you select the member allocated to the role.
If the role is set as “This is a role for which members can sign up” and the role has not been allocated to a member (by someone with agenda editing rights), or by another member having already selected the role, then any member can select the role.
If the setting “This is a role for which members can sign up” is NOT checked, then if the role has not been allocated by someone with editing rights, a member will NOT be able to select the role. It has to be allocated via the screen you are looking by someone with editing rights (aside from Admin and VPE, President and Toastmaster also have editing rights once the agenda has been created).
When you use the asterisk function, the role only has to be allocated to the first agenda item for that role, and the system will automatically populate all of the other agenda items for that role. That is why you don’t see the drop down box for *Toastmaster* introduces first speaker. If you scroll up the agenda you will see the dropdown box at the first *Toastmaster* agenda item. The *General Evaluator* role you see in your screen dump has the drop down available as this is the first occurrence of the General Evaluator on this agenda. It can only to be assigned (or selected if a signup role) here.
Once you have saved the agenda, log out as site admin and log in as member. You will see which roles can be selected by members. That should correspond to the settings of the “This is a role for which members can sign up”. The dropdown box in the edit view is NOT linked to that setting.
The topic has been locked.