Custom Domain Question

I just got off the phone with GoDaddy for the second time in two days. Sent them the page you referred me to for the second time in two days. Despite my protests that these are the instructions I am told we are to follow for FreeToastHost websites, they did not seem to think the instructions were correct for them. I'm attaching a screen shot of where we are now. I guess I just have to wait another 24 hours to see if it works?

Well, no 2-24 hours later for us. it looks like. It is all now magically working. Thank you for the feedback helping us get where we need to go!

There normally is a lag of about a day when you make DNS changes... This is normal.