Entering Multiple new members

I am the administrator of Eyeopenrs 2607 website and I am having problems entering all 5 new member.  The first two went as usual and the "op in" email was generated and sent to the first two and I received a confirmation that the email was sent.  There after I was not able to save and the 3rd would not appear as a strike thru.  Has anyone else seen this problem.  More importantly does anyone have a solution for this problem.

I see the following four members in the Members table with info stricken through, indicating not-yet-received opt-in permission: Adelaine, Jenn, Maddy, and Ross.
Are you properly entering people on the Quick Add tab?  I see that many phone numbers in your records are wrongly formatted, which is not a show stopper, but it might indicate sloppy handling in some other regard.
Not knowing what you mean by "all 5 new member" and "first two" and "3rd," (names would be helpful, it is difficult to offer a remedy.
 

Also make sure that they aren't already on your system as Prospect or Guests.  The system won't allow duplicates.  If they're already there you'll need to move them to the Members list